Person Page - 138

     Clara Tuthill was born circa 1866 at OH.¹ She was the daughter of John Claspill Tuthill and Mary A. Wilson.¹ Clara Tuthill appeared on the census of 15 June 1880 in the household of John Claspill Tuthill at 4th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John C. TUTHILL Self M Male W 39 OH Book Merchant NY OH
Mary TUTHILL Wife M Female W 36 OH Keeping House OH VA
Fanchon TUTHILL Dau S Female W 13 OH At School OH OH
Rosa TUTHILL Dau S Female W 12 OH At School OH OH
Aeckie TUTHILL Dau S Female W 10 OH At School OH OH
Clara TUTHILL Dau S Female W 4 OH OH OH
Fannie TIBBS Other S Female B 16 OH Servant OH OH (in this same home?).

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 79E01366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04AD1. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 22191466D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F02DC6. Mahala Jane (?) Person Source.⁴ Her married name was Tuthill.¹ Mahala Jane (?) was also known as Mahala Jane Claspill. Her married name was Tuthill. She was born circa 1822 at VA.¹ She was born on 9 January 1822 at near Charlestown, Virginia. She married John Lambert Tuthill, son of John Tuthill, on 4 October 1838. Mahala Jane (?) married John Lambert Tuthill, son of John Tuthill, before 1841.¹ Mahala Jane (?) appeared on the census of 1 August 1850 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John, 40, Bookbinder, NY
Jane, 28, VA
John, 8, OH
Louisa, 1/12, OH
Elizabeth Claspell, 70, VA
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1850. Mahala Jane (?) appeared on the census of 30 June 1860 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John L., 50, postmaster, Staten (Is?) NY
Mahala (J.?), 38, VA
John C., 18, OH
Geo. W. B., 4, OH
Edward, 2, OH
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1860. Mahala Jane (?) appeared on the census of 29 June 1870 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at dwelling 95, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L., 61, Editor Eagle, NY
Mahala J., 48, Va
George, 13, OH
Edward, 11, OH
Next to son John C. Mahala Jane (?) appeared on the census of 19 June 1880 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at 4th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L. TUTHILL Self M Male W 72 NY Book Seller NY CT
Jane TUTHILL Wife M Female W 58 VA Keeping House VA VA
Edward TUTHILL Son M Male W 21 OH Clerks In B Store NY VA
Catherine TUTHILL DauL M Female W 19 OH At Home OH OH. Mahala Jane (?) died on 31 October 1892 at Columbus Insane Asylum..⁵

     Louisa Tuthill Person Source.² Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 27514733679FD911BFCC0800460222F0CF72. Louisa Tuthill was also known as Elizabeth Anna Tuthill. She was born on 16 June 1850 at Lancaster, Ohio. She was born in July 1850 at OH.¹ She was the daughter of John Lambert Tuthill and Mahala Jane (?).¹ Louisa Tuthill appeared on the census of 1 August 1850 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John, 40, Bookbinder, NY
Jane, 28, VA
John, 8, OH
Louisa, 1/12, OH
Elizabeth Claspell, 70, VA
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1850. Louisa Tuthill died on 29 September 1850 at Lancaster, Ohio, at age 0. She died before 1860; assumed from her absence in the 1860 census.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 42191466D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04DC6. George W.B. Tuthill Person Source.² He Person Source.³ George W.B. Tuthill was also known as George Tuthill. He and Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter As of 1900, parents of 5, 3 living. George W.B. Tuthill was born in December 1855 at OH.^1,4 He was the son of John Lambert Tuthill and Mahala Jane (?).¹ George W.B. Tuthill was born on 28 December 1855 at Lancaster, Ohio. He appeared on the census of 30 June 1860 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John L., 50, postmaster, Staten (Is?) NY
Mahala (J.?), 38, VA
John C., 18, OH
Geo. W. B., 4, OH
Edward, 2, OH
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1860. George W.B. Tuthill appeared on the census of 29 June 1870 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at dwelling 95, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L., 61, Editor Eagle, NY
Mahala J., 48, Va
George, 13, OH
Edward, 11, OH
Next to son John C. George W.B. Tuthill married Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter on 6 June 1878 at date is newspaper issue date, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; "George W. Tuthill, brother of J.C.Tuthill, married Sallie F., eldest daughter of Col. Henry Hunter."⁵ George W.B. Tuthill appeared on the census of 2 June 1880 at 5th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Ann HUNTER Self W Female W 78 KY Keeping House NJ PA
Ruth MATTOCK Sister Female W 67 OH NJ PA
Helen N. CORNYN Dau W Female W 48 OH At Home OH KY
George TUTHILL Other M Male W 24 OH Clerks In Book Store NY VA
Sarah F. TUTHILL Other M Female W 23 OH Boarder OH NH
Ethel TUTHILL Other S Female W 8M OH OH OH
Clara HUNTER GDau S Female W 23 CA At Home OH KY
Harry HUNTER GSon S Male W 15 CA At Home OH KY
Maggie GRIFFITH Other S Female W 37 OH Servant PA PA. He appeared on the census of 4 June 1900 at Haddon, Camden, NJ; George W., b. Dec 1855, age 44, m. 21 years, OH, NY, Near VA, Salesman B & L
Sarah, Apr 1867, age 48, mother of 5, 3 living, OH OH NH
John G., son, Apr 1881, ND OH OH
Constance C., dau, Oct 1885, OH OH OH.

     Edward B. Tuthill Person Source.⁴ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 29514733679FD911BFCC0800460222F0D192. He married Catherine Craft.^5,2 Edward B. Tuthill was born circa 1858 at OH.³ He was the son of John Lambert Tuthill and Mahala Jane (?).³ Edward B. Tuthill was born on 17 June 1858 at Lancaster, Ohio. He appeared on the census of 30 June 1860 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John L., 50, postmaster, Staten (Is?) NY
Mahala (J.?), 38, VA
John C., 18, OH
Geo. W. B., 4, OH
Edward, 2, OH
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1860. Edward B. Tuthill appeared on the census of 29 June 1870 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at dwelling 95, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L., 61, Editor Eagle, NY
Mahala J., 48, Va
George, 13, OH
Edward, 11, OH
Next to son John C. Edward B. Tuthill was a witness In the 1880 Census the only Tuthills in Fairfield Co. are John L. Tuthill and his 3 boys. From this it is nearly certain that John H is son of John C., George W. or Edward. with John Lambert Tuthill in 1880. Edward B. Tuthill appeared on the census of 19 June 1880 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at 4th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L. TUTHILL Self M Male W 72 NY Book Seller NY CT
Jane TUTHILL Wife M Female W 58 VA Keeping House VA VA
Edward TUTHILL Son M Male W 21 OH Clerks In B Store NY VA
Catherine TUTHILL DauL M Female W 19 OH At Home OH OH. Edward B. Tuthill witnessed the death of Catherine Craft in 1888.² Edward B. Tuthill and Catherine Craft In the 1900 Census, there's not an E or C Tuthill found who was born in Ohio. in 1900. Edward B. Tuthill died on 11 October 1918 at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH.²

     Her married name was Tuthill.¹ Catherine Craft married Edward B. Tuthill, son of John Lambert Tuthill and Mahala Jane (?).^1,2 Catherine Craft was born circa 1861 at OH.¹ She appeared on the census of 19 June 1880 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at 4th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; John L. TUTHILL Self M Male W 72 NY Book Seller NY CT
Jane TUTHILL Wife M Female W 58 VA Keeping House VA VA
Edward TUTHILL Son M Male W 21 OH Clerks In B Store NY VA
Catherine TUTHILL DauL M Female W 19 OH At Home OH OH. Catherine Craft died in 1888.² She and Edward B. Tuthill In the 1900 Census, there's not an E or C Tuthill found who was born in Ohio. in 1900.

     Elizabeth Claspill - Claspell was born circa 1780 at VA.¹ She appeared on the census of 1 August 1850 in the household of John Lambert Tuthill at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Tuthill
John, 40, Bookbinder, NY
Jane, 28, VA
John, 8, OH
Louisa, 1/12, OH
Elizabeth Claspell, 70, VA
This is the only Tuthill family in Fairfield Co. in 1850.

     Her married name was Tuthill.¹ Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter and George W.B. Tuthill As of 1900, parents of 5, 3 living. Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter was born in April 1867 at OH.³ She married George W.B. Tuthill, son of John Lambert Tuthill and Mahala Jane (?), on 6 June 1878 at date is newspaper issue date, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; "George W. Tuthill, brother of J.C.Tuthill, married Sallie F., eldest daughter of Col. Henry Hunter."¹ Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter appeared on the census of 2 June 1880 in the household of George W.B. Tuthill at 5th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Ann HUNTER Self W Female W 78 KY Keeping House NJ PA
Ruth MATTOCK Sister Female W 67 OH NJ PA
Helen N. CORNYN Dau W Female W 48 OH At Home OH KY
George TUTHILL Other M Male W 24 OH Clerks In Book Store NY VA
Sarah F. TUTHILL Other M Female W 23 OH Boarder OH NH
Ethel TUTHILL Other S Female W 8M OH OH OH
Clara HUNTER GDau S Female W 23 CA At Home OH KY
Harry HUNTER GSon S Male W 15 CA At Home OH KY
Maggie GRIFFITH Other S Female W 37 OH Servant PA PA.

     Ethel Tuthill was born in 1879 at OH.¹ She was the daughter of George W.B. Tuthill and Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter.¹ Ethel Tuthill appeared on the census of 2 June 1880 in the household of George W.B. Tuthill at 5th ward, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; Ann HUNTER Self W Female W 78 KY Keeping House NJ PA
Ruth MATTOCK Sister Female W 67 OH NJ PA
Helen N. CORNYN Dau W Female W 48 OH At Home OH KY
George TUTHILL Other M Male W 24 OH Clerks In Book Store NY VA
Sarah F. TUTHILL Other M Female W 23 OH Boarder OH NH
Ethel TUTHILL Other S Female W 8M OH OH OH
Clara HUNTER GDau S Female W 23 CA At Home OH KY
Harry HUNTER GSon S Male W 15 CA At Home OH KY
Maggie GRIFFITH Other S Female W 37 OH Servant PA PA.

     John G. Tuthill was born in April 1881 at SD.¹ He was the son of George W.B. Tuthill and Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter.¹

     Constance C. Tuthill was born in October 1885 at OH.¹ She was the daughter of George W.B. Tuthill and Sarah (Sallie) F. Hunter.¹

     Frank Tuthill and Russell Edward Tuthill Compare the siblings list in Russells obit with this child list of Frank. Frank Tuthill was born on 2 February 1885 at Fairfield, OH.^2,1 He was the son of Edward B. Tuthill and Catherine Craft.¹ Frank Tuthill married Alice Mae Newman on 28 May 1910.^2,1 Frank Tuthill appeared on the census of 8 January 1920 at Columbus St., Dist. 22, Lancaster, Fairfield, OH; image 15 of 29. He witnessed the death of Alice Mae Newman on 2 April 1923 at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH.¹ Frank Tuthill was Evidently the 3 youngest were put up for adoption after their mother's death. The oldest were farmed out as hired help. after 2 April 1923. He died on 31 January 1934 at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH, at age 48.¹ He was buried after 31 January 1934 at Lancaster, Fairfield, OH.¹

     James Tuthill was born after 1888. He was the son of Edward B. Tuthill.¹

     Her married name was Kellenbarger.¹ Elizabeth (?) married Jerome Kellenbarger, son of Joseph Kellenbarger and Maggie Funk.¹ Elizabeth (?) was born in 1902.¹ She was buried in 1974 at Logan, OH.¹ She died in 1974.¹

      Lucy A. Atkinson was also known as Atkins.¹ Her married name was Thomas.³ Lucy A. Atkinson was also known as Lucy An (?).⁴ She was born in 1828 at VA.³ She married Joseph T. Thomas on 11 September 1845 at Wayne, IN.^3,1,5 Lucy A. Atkinson appeared on the census of 1850 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas at Green Twp, Wayne, IN; Joseph T., 29, Cooper, NC
Lucy A., 22, VA
Martha, 3, IN
William H., 2, IN

There's just one other Thomas born in NC in Green twp this year: Andrew, b. c. 1816...maybe a brother?

Be sure to check Randolph Co., though, as this area of Wayne Co. is near Randolph. Lucy A. Atkinson appeared on the census of 1860 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas at Dwelling 207, West River Twp, Randolph, IN; Thomas, James T., 41, NC
Lucy A., 32, VA
Martha J., 13, IN
J. Q., 9, IN
Rebeca, 5, IN. Lucy A. Atkinson and Joseph T. Thomas appeared on the census of 1870 at West River Twp, Randolph, IN; Thomas, James T., 49, Cooper, 2000, 300, NC
Lucy An, 42, Keeps House, VA
Martha J., 25, IN
John Q., 19, IN
Rebecca A., 14, IN
Liman?, G., 10, IN
Elmer? E., 2, IN

Note: Two pages away is William Chamness, age 76, born in NC.

While the first name is written "James", this, based on the child list from the 1860 Census, is most certainly Joseph. -RJ. Lucy A. Atkinson died on 14 April 1888; Possible error: See notes on the Burial Tag.⁶ She was buried after 14 April 1888 at Union Chapel Cemetery, Randolph, IN; Transcription reads "Joseph T. Thomas Lucy A. Thomas died 4th mo. 14th day in the year 1888; aged ? y. 2 m. ?d."

This transcription was, early in 2005, found on one of the pages of Randolph Co. IN GenWeb (source 653), but is not found as of June, 2005.

Waynet (Source 755) shows this cemetery, and a Joseph Thomas there, but no Lucy - and no birth or death dates for Joseph.

In 1908, the County Directory shows, for Lucy's grandson Otis:
Otis, (Ivel) laborer, w First (Lucy). I know of no other Lucy's than his grandmother...so maybe the stone is referring to Joseph and Lucy's son James, who we know did die in 1888.^6,7 She lived with Otis Ray Thomas and Ival M. Bennett in 1908 at W. First, Modoc, Randolph, IN; Entry reads "Ottis, (Ivel) laborer, w First (Lucy).

The only known Lucy in the family is Otis' Grandmother, who we thought died in 1888...but it is possible that the stone on which this date appears is referencing Otis' father James, rather than Lucy. See the information on the Burial tag for grandmother Lucy -RJ.⁸

     William H. Thomas was born circa 1848 at IN.¹ He was the son of Joseph T. Thomas and Lucy A. Atkinson.¹ William H. Thomas appeared on the census of 1850 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas at Green Twp, Wayne, IN; Joseph T., 29, Cooper, NC
Lucy A., 22, VA
Martha, 3, IN
William H., 2, IN

There's just one other Thomas born in NC in Green twp this year: Andrew, b. c. 1816...maybe a brother?

Be sure to check Randolph Co., though, as this area of Wayne Co. is near Randolph. William H. Thomas died before 1860; assumed from absence in 1860 census family.¹

      Rebecca Angeline Thomas was also known as Angie.² She was born in January 1856 at IN.¹ She was the daughter of Joseph T. Thomas and Lucy A. Atkinson.^3,1 Rebecca Angeline Thomas appeared on the census of 1860 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas at Dwelling 207, West River Twp, Randolph, IN; Thomas, James T., 41, NC
Lucy A., 32, VA
Martha J., 13, IN
J. Q., 9, IN
Rebeca, 5, IN. Rebecca Angeline Thomas appeared on the census of 1870 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas and Lucy A. Atkinson at West River Twp, Randolph, IN; Thomas, James T., 49, Cooper, 2000, 300, NC
Lucy An, 42, Keeps House, VA
Martha J., 25, IN
John Q., 19, IN
Rebecca A., 14, IN
Liman?, G., 10, IN
Elmer? E., 2, IN

Note: Two pages away is William Chamness, age 76, born in NC.

While the first name is written "James", this, based on the child list from the 1860 Census, is most certainly Joseph. -RJ. As of 2 January 1878,her married name was Chamness.⁴ Rebecca Angeline Thomas married Daniel T. Chamness on 2 January 1878 at Randolph, IN; Record Location: Randolph County Indiana
Compiled by Margaret Snyder
Spouse 1: Daniel T Chamness
Spouse 2: Augie R. Thomas
Marriage Date: 02 Jan 1878
County: Randolph
Original Source Page: 7
Name: Wm. B. Jones.^4,2 Rebecca Angeline Thomas appeared on the census of 28 April 1910 in the household of Joseph T. Thomas and Daniel T. Chamness at Washington Twp., Randolph, IN; 1910 Census Washington twp. Randolph Co. IN
THOMAS, Joseph 89 b. NC (Father in Law)
CHAMNESS:
Daniel 54 b. IN fa. b. NC mo. b. NC
Rebecca 53 b. IN fa b. NC mo. b. WVA
They have a son Merton Z. b. Jan. 1878

Per Diane, Rebecca is found as Rebecca A. & Angeline in different censuses.

Ancestry.com shows both Daniel and Chamness and Joseph Thomas in the index, and both point to the same page in district 146, but the family is not found there. RJ searched every page of the 3 districts of Washington Twp, at Ancestry.com, and could not find this family.⁵

     Her married name was Thomas.¹ Nancy J. Hardwick was born circa 1861 at IN.¹ She married John Q. Thomas, son of Joseph T. Thomas and Lucy A. Atkinson, on 16 June 1878 at Randolph, IN; Performed By Wm. Wones.

This marriage record is presumed match. Note, though: another researcher has this John Q. Thomas as having different parents than I show:
http://awt.ancestry.com/cgi-bin/igm.cgi?op=GET&db=:2937316&id=I16.^1,2 Nancy J. Hardwick appeared on the census of 15 June 1880 in the household of John Q. Thomas at dwelling 125, West River, Randolph, IN; John Q., 28, Farmer, IN NC VA
Nancy J., 19, wife, IN IN IN
William R., 7/12, son, IN IN IN. Nancy J. Hardwick appeared on the census of 25 June 1880 in the household of John Q. Thomas at dwelling 288, West River, Randolph, IN; John, 29, Farmer, IN OH OH
Nancy J., 19, wife, IN IN IN
William R., 8/12, son, IN IN IN.

     William R. Thomas was born in December 1879 at IN.¹ He was the son of John Q. Thomas and Nancy J. Hardwick.¹ William R. Thomas appeared on the census of 15 June 1880 in the household of John Q. Thomas at dwelling 125, West River, Randolph, IN; John Q., 28, Farmer, IN NC VA
Nancy J., 19, wife, IN IN IN
William R., 7/12, son, IN IN IN. William R. Thomas appeared on the census of 25 June 1880 in the household of John Q. Thomas at dwelling 288, West River, Randolph, IN; John, 29, Farmer, IN OH OH
Nancy J., 19, wife, IN IN IN
William R., 8/12, son, IN IN IN.

     Joshua Horton The Horton Family in America: 'Children by 2) : (All born in Southold, Long Island, New York.) Joshua, b. about 1643; m. Mary Tuthill, 1667; d. 1729.' He Person Source.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 90C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0437F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 93C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F046AF. He was born in 1643 at Southold, Long Island, New York. He married Mary Tuthill, daughter of Henry Tuthill and Bridget Elizabeth Burton, in 1665. Joshua Horton died on 17 June 1729 at Southold, Long Island, New York.²

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 92C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0459F. Her married name was Wells. Her married name was Tuthill. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 97C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04AEF. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 99C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04C0F. Bridget Elizabeth Burton was born in 1616.¹ She married Henry Tuthill in 1634 at England.² Bridget Elizabeth Burton married William Wells, son of William Wells, in 1654 at Southold, Long Island, New York. Bridget Elizabeth Burton died in 1655 at Southold, Long Island, New York.³

     William Wells was buried at Southold Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island, New York.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 94C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F047BF. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 9BC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04E2F. He was born on 5 May 1660 at Southold, Long Island, New York. He was the son of William Wells and Mary Youngs. William Wells married Elizabeth Tuthill, daughter of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, on 1 June 1681 at Southold, Suffolk, New York. William Wells died on 17 October 1696 at Cutchogue, Suffolk, New York, at age 36.

     John Tuthill Person Source.¹ He Person Source.² He Person Source.³ He Person Source.⁴ He Person Source.⁵ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID A2C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0559F. He '4 JOHN TUTHILL, son of Henry and Bridget Tuthill was born July 16, 1635, died at Southold, L. I. Oct. 12, 1717. He married in Southold, Feb. 17, 1657, Deliverance, daughter of William and Dorothy King, who died there Jan. 24, 1688/9, aged 49 years. He married second, May 28, 1690, Sarah probably widow of Thomas Young and daughter of John Frost. She died Nov. 8, 1727. His family Bible was in existence in 1898. His marriage and the births of his children are recorded in the Town Records of Southold. His home lot in that town was where the Universalist Church now stands. Many parcels of land in Oysterponds, Southold, Corchaug and Occabauk stand in his name on the Town Records. He was a trusty public officer and a worthy private citizen.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 80.

SOURCE: Tuttle, Alva M., Master Index - Film #1206456. '...He moved from Southold to Oysterponds about 1665 and live about one mile from the tip of the Island. His two neighbors at that early day were Samuel King, brother of Deliverance his wife, and Richard Brown, who had married a sister of Samuel and Deliverance. These three families lived in peace and loving friendship for over forty years; buying and selling land together, with never a word written to bind their bargains. Children, (records from John's own Bible) : John b. Feb 14, 1658; Eizabeth b. Jan 19, 1661; Henry b. May 1, 1665; Hannah b. Nov. 7, 1667; Abigail b. Oct. 17, 1670; Dorothy b. Oct 16, 1674; Deliverance b. Aug. 2, 1677; Daniel b. Jan 23, 1680; Nathaniel b. Nov. 10, 1683. 2nd Mar.: Mary Youngs d. Jan 11 1699 at 8 years.' (Tuthill Ancessary of Olive Tuthill Young, Buffalo, New York - 9th Generation.'

Note 6. 'John2 Tuthill (Henry1) was a man of great enterprise, energy and will, controlled and guided by strong common sense, honesty of purpose, and religious principle. No man had, perhaps, to so great an extent, the confidence of the community, as the record trusts of Richard Brown and others, bear ampel testimony. Tuthill was a trusty public officer and a worthy private citizen.' 'J.W.C.' in Southold Town Records.
'John Tuthill's first wife was Deliverance Kinge (William1). Her sister Hannah married Lieut. Richard2 Brown (Richard1).
'John Tuthill, Richard Brown and Samuel Kinge (brother of Deliverance and Hannah) formed a remarkable trio, being no less noted for their steady friendship for each other, than for their stirling integrity.
'Samuel Kinge is buried in the old Orient Cemetery.
'Are the last resting places of John Tuthill or of Richard Brown known?
'Richard Brown appears to have owned the ground which is now the cemetery. It would be a happy thing could we know that the three friends were sleeping the last sleep, side by side. A Tuthill Descendant' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 101.)

Gentry
'121. Mr. John Tuthill, Srl, John Tuthill, Esq. (Both titles being given to John, husband of Deliverance King, and his son, who married Mehitable Wells. See Vol. II, p. 193, 199, 150, Town Records.)' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 125.). Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: ADC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0604F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: AFC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0626F. He was born on 16 July 1635 at Southold, Long Island, New York. He was the son of Henry Tuthill and Bridget Elizabeth Burton. John Tuthill married Deliverance King, daughter of William King and Dorothy Hayne, on 17 February 1656/57 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.⁶ John Tuthill married Sarah Frost on 28 May 1690. John Tuthill died on 12 October 1717 at Oysterponds, Long Island, New York, at age 82.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID A8C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F05BFF. Bethia Horton The Hortons in America: The Old Bible by Dr. Horton: ''Lydia Horton, her book, given her by her mother, as it is said'. And then follows: 'February 8, in the year 1742, then Jonathan Tuthill departed this life - the son of Henry Tuthill and Bethia (Horton) Tuthill. Susanna Tuthill, wife of Jonathan Tuthill, departed this life May 16, in the year 1743, in the 50th year of her age. Henry Tuthill, departd this life the 4th of January, in the year 1750, aged 84. Bethia Tuthill, wife of Henry Tuthill, departed this life March 16, 1744, in the 73d year of her age.''

'214. The direct descent of Bethia Tuthill, wife of Samuel2 Landon, (Nathan1) in her Horton ancestry was: 1. Barnabas Horton, burried in an alter tomb at Southold, died July 13, 1680, aged 80 years; he was born in Mousely, Leicestershire, England. (Whether Mary, the wife of Barnabas, was his only wife, or his second wife or the mother of his children, seems uncertain.) 2. Capt. Jonathan Horton, born at Southold, Feb. 23, 1648, died there Feb.23, 1707, married there about 1672, Bethia2 Wells, daughter of William1 and Marie (Youngs?) Wells, born about 1653 or 1655, died at Southold April 14, 1733/4. 3. Bethia Horton, born about 1674, died at Southold Mar. 16, 1744 (Horton Bible, brought by Barnabas to America), married in or before 1690. Henry3 Tuthill (John2 Henry1), of Southold, born there May 1, 1665, died Jan 4, 1750, also at Southold, 4 Bethia Tuthill, born Dec 12, 1703, died Aug. 30, 1761; married May 26, 1721, Samuel2 Landon, Judge in Suffolk Co. before the Revolution.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 75.). Her married name was Tuthill. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: B5C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F068CF. She was born circa 1674.¹ She was the daughter of Jonathan Horton and Bethiah Wells. Bethia Horton married Henry Tuthill, son of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, in 1688 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.² Bethia Horton died on 16 March 1743/44 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.³

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 9BC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04E2F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID B4C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F067BF. Her married name was Goldsmith. Her married name was Wells. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: B1C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0648F. Elizabeth Tuthill was born on 19 January 1661 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.^1,2,3 She was the daughter of John Tuthill and Deliverance King. Elizabeth Tuthill married William Wells, son of William Wells and Mary Youngs, on 1 June 1681 at Southold, Suffolk, New York. Elizabeth Tuthill married John Goldsmith on 2 February 1696/97.⁴ Elizabeth Tuthill died after October 1705 at of Cutchogue, Suffolk, New York.

     Joshua Wells Justice 'JOSHUA WELLS, son of William and Mary Wells, was born in Southold in 1664 and died May 2, 1744. He married there Jan. 19, 1686, Hannah, born Nov. 7, 1667, died July 27, 1752, daughter of John and Deliverance (King) Tuthill. They are buried at Cutchogue. He was a Justice of the Peace for many years. In 1684 his mother gave him that part of his father's land known as 'Pooles Neck' and there he built his home and always lived, the house standing opposite of the residence of Josiah Albertson at Cutchogue. It was occupied by his son Joshua who left it to his son John, but it was burned in 1828 while in possession of John's daughters, Sarah and Hannah.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 84.

(cont. from Suffolk Times article of August 10, 2000)
The Old Place was first situated 300 yards east of New Suffolk Avenue, roughly where Wickham's Fruit Farm is today, according to Mr. Grathwohl. Around 1815 it was moved across the street, where Ivy League Flower and Gifts now stands.
In those days, he said, farmers would spend what they could to build a house. As they prospered the custom was to either deed the old house to a family member - a son or a daughter - and build a new one, or extensively renovate and expand the old one.

The Fleet connection
Mary Holland a descendant of Augustine Fleet (1806-1846), and her son, Matthew, are the last generation of Fleets on the North Fork. She provided a genealogical record that shows Joshua Well's great-granddaughter, Sarah (1767-1838), married John Fleet in 1789. Her father, John (1729-1797), owned the Old Place when the British seized it.
Before his death in 1797 he left lands known as Pequash Neck to his daughter Abigail, the wife of Joseph Hull Goldsmith, and Poole's Neck to his other daughters, Hannah and Sarah. William Wells first received them for his services in negotiating the 1667 treaty with the Corchaug Indians to extend Southold's boundaries.
Sarah and John Fleet had a son, Joshua, before John died in 1790. Sarah later married Ransler Fleet (1763-1812), John's cousin, and had two sons, Augustine and John. Hannah deeded to Sarah her share of the land in 1818, and Sarah, in turn, deeded to Augustine that portion on Feb. 23, 1838. Sarah's own half went to Joshua, who deeded the 200 acres to Augustine on Oct. 21, 1829. Thus the Wells property came into the Fleet family and was thereafter known as Fleet's Neck.
Sarah's son Joshua then married a woman named Frances (last name unknown), aka 'Madam Fleet,' according to Ms. Holland.
Mr. Grathwohl said the new Ms. Fleet 'wanted a modern house' and hired craftsmen from New York City to renovate it - around 1815 - to the then-popular Federal style.
Although much has been made of Ms. Fleet's motivation to do so, Mrs. Holland credits her 'with fixing up the house,' This is shown by the attention to detail still evident today - the five hand-carved mantelpieces, molding, dormer windows and the front door, which has its original eagle knocker.
The 'new' owners
The house left Fleet hands in 1857 when Henry Landon Fleet (1832-1894), son of Augustine and Rhoda Terry Fleet - and a horse breeder and farmer - sold it to Orrin T. Goldsmith - the great nephew of Sarah Wells Fleet's sister Abigail and a direct descendant of John Goldsmith, whose wife was Anna Wells, sister of the Old Place's builder. Right after the sale it was moved a quarter of a mile during a week's period to its present location, on 1.7 acres,with the help of 20 oxen.
According to a later owner, Athelstane Kendrick, whose wife was a niece of Mr. Goldsmith's, the family said the house 'suffered not the slightest damage in the journey despite the fact that it was moved complete with chimney...an indication...(of) its own remarkable solidity.'
Mr. Kendrick's wife inherited the place from her cousin, Oliver Benjamin Goldsmith, in 1924. Their daughter, Connie Kendrick Overton, sold the house in 1965 to Elizabeth Vernon and Angelina Ferro of New York City. Ms. Vernon rented the house from that time until February before deciding to put it on the market.
When Mr. Grathwohl found out through sources the house was up for grabs in March he said he called 'the next day and sealed the deal.' The official closing date was Wednesday, July 25.
Although he'''s a Virginia resident, Mr. Grathwohl still has family in Cutchogue and would eventually like to move back. He plans to create a 'before and after' Chamber of Commerce house tour to mark his restoration progress.
'I want it to be a showplace, so give me five years or so,' he said. He Person Source.¹ He Person Source.² Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID B6C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F069DF. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: C7C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F07AEF. He was born in 1664 at of Suffolk, New York.³ He was the son of William Wells and Mary Youngs. Joshua Wells Justice married Hannah Tuthill, daughter of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, on 19 January 1685/86 at Southold, Suffolk, New York. Joshua Wells Justice died on 7 May 1744.⁴

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID CAC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F07D1F. Henry Tuthill Campbell, pg. 2 & 216.

The Long Island Traveler, Southold, New York, pg. 10: 'The old Horton Bible has the dates of death of Henry, Bethia, Jonathan and Susannah, so we are safe in inferring that the husband of Susannah L'Hommedieu was the son of Henry and Bethia, before mentioned. Jonathan and his wife Susanah, are buried in the old cemetery ar Orient where it is said Jonathan Jrl, who died in 1725-26 is also interred. Benjamin Tuthill, born about 1726-27, died Feb 10, 1748/9, in his 23rd year, is buried close by and the only other Tuthill gravestones are in other parts of the cemetery. Why could not Benjamin have been the son of Jonathan and Susannah Tuthill and named after his maternal grandfather Benjamin L'Homedieu?'

The Hortons in America: The Old Bible by Dr. Horton: ''Lydia Horton, her book, given her by her mother, as it is said'. And then follows: 'February 8, in the year 1742, then Jonathan Tuthill departed this life - the son of Henry Tuthill and Bethia (Horton) Tuthill. Susanna Tuthill, wife of Jonathan Tuthill, departed this life May 16, in the year 1743, in the 50th year of her age. Henry Tuthill, departd this life the 4th of January, in the year 1750, aged 84. Bethia Tuthill, wife of Henry Tuthill, departed this life March 16, 1744, in the 73d year of her age.''

'Will of Henry Tuthill of Southold, dated Sept. 28, 1749, proved June 4, 1750, names sons Henry and his children Henry and Zipporah, son Jonathan, deceased, and his daughter Bethiah Tuthill; son Barnabas; daughter Bethia, wife of Sam'l Landon, Esq, grandaughter of Parnel Landon; also his grandchildren John Tuthill, and Deiverance, wife of Elisha Pain. Executors, son Henry Tuthill and son-in-law Samuel Landon. Witnesses, Joseph Brown, Dorithy Brown and Jonathan Barber. (Silver spoons are disposed of by the above will, and land in the Towns of Southold and Brookhaven.) Liber 17, p. 118, N.Y. City Wills.) (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 69.)

Bits of Southold History. Notable Marriages:
'Perhaps the oldest man ever celebrating a marriage in Southold, at least the oldest so far as can be learned, was Jonathan Goldsmith Horton, who at the age of 81 years and 6 months was united in matrimony to widow Bethiah Overton Brown, aged 66. Mr. Horton, or 'Uncle Goopie,' as everybody called him, was the sixth direct Jonathan to live in the 'old castle' on the home lot of Barnabas Horton, who in 1640 built his home where George C. Terry's house now stands, corner of Horton Lane and Main street. Uncle Goopie was Drum Major of the 107th Regiment, N. Y. Militia, in 1812, and Deputy Sheriff of Suffolk County in 1814.
'In this old Horton House occured a double marriage in the year 1706, viz., Henry Tuthill to Bethiah Horton, and Daniel Tuthill to Mehetabel Horton Henry and Daniel were brothers and grandsons of the first John Tuthill of Southold, and Bethiah and Mehetabel were granddaughters of the first Barnabas Horton.
'This Bethiah Horton who married Henry Tuthill was great-great-grandmother to Mrs. Anna Harrison, wife of President William Henry Harrison.' (The Long Island Traveler, Friday, Sept. 3, 1909, pg. 918.). Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: B5C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F068CF. He was born on 1 May 1665 at Southold, Long Island, New York.^1,2 He was the son of John Tuthill and Deliverance King. Henry Tuthill married Bethia Horton, daughter of Jonathan Horton and Bethiah Wells, in 1688 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.³ Henry Tuthill died on 4 January 1749/50 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York, at age 84.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID D6C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F089DF. Her married name was Tuthill. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: E9C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F09C0F. Elizabeth Browne was born in 1686 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. She was the daughter of Jonathan Browne. Elizabeth Browne married John Tuthill III, son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells, circa 1706 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. Elizabeth Browne died on 22 October 1750 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.¹

     Jonathan Tuthill died BET. 1743 - 1744 at Goshen, Orange, New York. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID D8C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F08BFF. He Long Island Traveler, pg. 59, Item #15 - 'The oldest son, Jonathan, (of John Tuthill 4th & Elizabeth) married in 1727, Mary Vail, and went to Orange Co, in all probability.' Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: EDC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0A04F. He was born in 1707 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. He was the son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne. Jonathan Tuthill married Mary Vail on 8 March 1727/28 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.¹

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID DAC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F08D1F. John Tuthill Long Island Traveler pg. 59, Item #15 - 'John 2nd son (John 4th & Elizabeth) married in 1744 Abigail Lambert, but apparently had but two children, John, and Lydia.'

'576. Wanted - the parentage of Abigail Lambert, who married John Tuthill Nov. 15, 1744. John Tuthill was called 'Hollow John'. He died in 1795, aged 86.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 160.)

See notes on Abigail Lambert. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: EFC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0A26F. He was born in 1709 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. He was the son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne. John Tuthill married Abigail Lambert, daughter of John Lambert, on 15 November 1744.¹ John Tuthill died on 26 October 1794 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.