Person Page - 140

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 20C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0D59D. John Tuthill III '5. JOHN TUTHILL, son of John and Mehitable (Wells) Tuthill, died in Southold, June 29, 1743, aged 60 years. He married Elizabeth whose parentage has not been definitely settled, but perhaps she was a daughter of Jonathan Browne. His will dated June 9, 1740, proven Aug. 6, 1745 is filed in New York City. In it he mentions his wife Elizabeth and wishes her to send their son Samuel to College. He states that Jonathan is his eldest son and bequeaths him land in the Highlands which is now located in the vicinity of West Point. He names his other sons as John, Jeremiah, Isaiah, Nathan and his daughters as Elizabeth Terry, Hannah, and Mary Brown leaving the latter one hundred acresof land near her brother Jonathan and also his property west of John Robinson's land lying in Brookhaven, L. I. He gives '3/4 of a right in the Manor land for the upholdidng of a preached Gospel at the Wading River, forever.' He made his brother Joshua Tuthill, his brother Joseph Browne and his son John Tuthill his executors.
'His wife Elizabeth was born in 1686 and died Oct. 21, 1750.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 81.





BIRTH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I23363@ @I4925@. He Person Source.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: E9C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F09C0F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 0FC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0C48D. He was born in 1683 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.² He was the son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. John Tuthill III married Elizabeth Browne, daughter of Jonathan Browne, circa 1706 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. John Tuthill III died on 29 June 1743 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: EDC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0A04F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 3EC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0F37D. Mary Vail SOURCE: Tuttle, Alva M., Master Index, (Vital Records - Film #12064560). 'Mary believed daughter of Jeremiah and Mary Vail of Oysterponds. She was born perhaps about 1808 and died in the spring of 1747, Goshen town NY. Jonathan and Mary came to Orange Co, perhaps as early as 1730 and settled in present Hamptonburgh (then Goshen township) near several of Mary's uncles Vail. Mary made a will dated Mar. 14, 1747 and which was proved May 8, 1747. There is a note of letters of Administration on estate of Jonathan issued Mar. 6, 1744 but the papers are lost. (NY Historical Society Collections of 1894, p. 428.) Mary's will open, 'I Mary Tuthill widow and executor of Jonathan Tuthill, intestate and leaves to her son William a roan horse, called Tin Ware, to Solomon a pacing mare, and a bed with linsey woolsey ticking, to Thomas a great iron pot, an to John a black horse.' Children: William, b. 1728-9; Solomon, b. 1730; Thomas b. 1732; John b. 1734; James b. abt 1736; another son about 1738; Mary b. 1740; Gamaliel b. 1742.' (Tuthill Ancessary of Olive Tuthill Young, Buffalo, New York - Sixth Generation.'

'551. 3. What is the Long Island ancestry of Jonathan Tuthill, whose widow Mary in her will dated 14 March,1 746-7, proved 8 May, same year, describes herself as of Goshen, Orange County, N.Y. and mentions son William Tuthill, and also Solomon Tuthill, Thomas Tuthil, and John Tuthill. Executor, James Tuthill; Witnesses, Abigail Norton, Patrick Mullen and Alexander Smith (Albany, N.Y., Wills, 1626-1836).' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 152.). Her married name was Tuthill. She was born circa 1708 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. She married Jonathan Tuthill, son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne, on 8 March 1727/28 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.¹ Mary Vail died before 8 May 1747 at Goshen, Orange, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: FFC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0B26F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 48C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0FD1D. Mary Tuthill



RECORDS: THE TUTHILL FAMILY OF THARSTON,Norfolk County, England.
BAPTISM; ENDOWED: IGI, dates found doing TEMPLE READY 7 April 1999.
SEALED TO PARENTS: IGI, date found doing TEMPLE READY 7 April 1999.
RELATIONSHIP: H. Reed Black (Uncle of Richard L. Ricks b. 1943)is not related.

BIRTH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I23394@ @I4926@. She Person Source.¹ Her married name was Horton. She was born in 1687 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.² She was the daughter of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Mary Tuthill married Jonathan Horton, son of Jonathan Horton and Bethiah Wells, on 27 November 1706 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.^3,4 Mary Tuthill was buried in March 1780 at Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island. She died on 4 March 1780 at Southold, Suffolk, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: EFC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0A26F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 50C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0059D. Abigail Lambert '324. In reply to 'E.T.', July 29, 1898, I will say that undobtedly the Deborah Glover who married David King was daughter of William and Deborah (Lambert) Glover, and she was his second wife; therefore I believe it was her mother who married secondly John Tuthill senior (widower.)' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 166.)

'576. Savage says Francis Lambert, of Rowley, was probably the father of Gershom Lambert, who settled in Stonigton, Conn., some time before 1698; but the first deed of his recorded there is of that date, in which he sells much land to John Seabury, of Duxborough, Plymouth Co., Mass. Deeds are aso found as late as 1728, not only to Seabury, but to his sons and others. In one deed dated 1705 he mentions lands received from his father-in-law from John Frink. In another deed in 1727 he conveys to his three sons: John, Gershom, Jr., and Jabez Lambert. In 1725 Deborah and Jabez Lambert convey to Nathaniel Cheesbrough. The conveyance is signed by Deborah, Jabez, Mary, and Abigail Lambert. On the town records of Stonington, Conn., are the following children to Gershom Lambert: John, born Aug. 10, 1687; Mary, born Jan. 30, 1690-1; Jabez, born Oct. 1700; Abigail, born Dec. 23, 1706. On the records of the First Congregational church at Stonington are the following baptsims: John Lambert, son of Gershom, baptized July 8, 1688; Deborah daughter of gershom, bapt. Oct. 5, 1690; Mary, daughter of Gershom, bapt. March 16, 1700; Abigail daughter of Gershom, bapt. May _ 1707. Then we have from deeds, church and town records, that Gershom Lambert married _____Frink, daughter of John. His children were John, Gershom, Mary, Jabez, Deborah and Abigail. Another record states that John Lambert (probably the above born 1687) was married by the Rev. Ebenezer Pemberton, pastor of a church in Boston, 25 June, 1713, to Abigail Hempstead (the name may be Bumpstead). They had children: John, born Feb., __1714-5; Gershom, born Dec. 28, 1715; Abigail, baptized May 3, 1719. I do not find that this John had other children. Can any one tell which of these two Abigails married John Tuthill, of Sterling (now Greenport), Nov. 14, 1744? See my notes below on
'Glover Lambert. In deed 1724 of William Glover (now resident of Stonington') to Nathaniel Cheesbrough, he sells land bought from his brother-in-law John Lambert, which he inherited from his father Gershom. I have records that Wiliam Glover married Deborah Lambert Oct. 29, 1712, and had children: William, born 1713; Deborah, Sarah, Daniel, John, born 1721, and Phebe, 1724. The Stonighton records give Phebey, daughter of William and Deborah Glover, as March 6, 1724. From another source I learn that William Glover, Jr., born 1713, was born at Southold, L.I., and married Mary Fanning, April 8, 1751. They removed to Plainfield, Conn., and then to Norwich, where he died in 1788. He left seven children. Anna married Erastus (?) Perkins; Mary, Prentice Peabody; Nathan, Desire Avery (?) William, lost at sea; James went to Oxford, N.Y., and finally became an early settler of Ottawa, Ill; Phebe married John Brown and died in the West Indies. From these various records we learn that William Glover married Deborah Lambert (daughter of Gershom) and that their eldest son was born at Southold in 1713, an that said William became, according to deeds, a resident of Stonington, Conn., about 1723, and his daughter Phebe was born there the following year. Can any one tell when this William died? and was it not his widow Deborah who married John Tuthill (widower), father of the John Tuthill who married Abigail Lambert?
'I am inclined to think instead of the two sisters (Deborah and Abigail Lambert) marrying the two Tuthills, that it was Aunt Deborah and niece Abigail, for I learn that Abigail (probably daughter of 1st John Lambert), baptized 1707, married Jonathan Whitaker and resided near Norwixh, Conn. So in all probability the Abigail (daughter of John son of Gershom) baptized May 3, 1719, is the one who married John Tuthill, Jr., and her aunt Deborah married John Tuthill, Sr.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 172.). Her married name was Tuthill. She was born in 1719 at Stonington, Connecticut. She was the daughter of John Lambert. Abigail Lambert was christened on 3 May 1719. She married John Tuthill, son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne, on 15 November 1744.¹ Abigail Lambert died on 8 September 1751 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York, at age 32.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 54C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F009DD. John Tuthill '248. John Tuthill, son of John and Abigail (Lambert) Tuthill, lived in Vermont in 1828. A letter in the possession of one of his grand nephews confirms the fact that he lived at Montpelier. Vt. The letter is addressed to 'Widow Lydia Youngs, Southold, Long Island, N.Y.' Above the address is written 'Forwarded from Southold,' showing that his sister, 'Widow Youngs,' had removed from Southold...On the lower left hand corner are the letters 'Montpelier, Vt. Feb. 26' enclosed in a circular rim, all in red ink. The inside date of the letter is 'Feb. 21st 1828.' It is written on foolscap size and filled with nearly three and a half pages, and signed, 'John Tuthill.'' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 80.). He Person Source.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 35C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0EAED. He was born in 1747 at Oysterponds, Long Island, New York.² He was the son of John Tuthill and Abigail Lambert. John Tuthill died on 23 September 1828 at Montpelier, Vermont.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 56C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00BFD. Lydia Tuthill Campbell, pg. 29, Lydia age 80 yr 5 mos. She Person Source.¹ Her married name was Youngs. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 39C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0EE2D. She was born in August 1750 at Oysterponds, Long Island, New York. She was the daughter of John Tuthill and Abigail Lambert. Lydia Tuthill married Thomas Youngs Deacon in 1773. Lydia Tuthill died on 13 January 1831 at Greensport, Long Island, New York, at age 80.²

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: F1C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0A48F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 58C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00D1D. Her married name was Tuthill. Hannah Terry was born in 1711 at Aquebogue, Suffolk, New York. She married Isaiah Tuthill, son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne, on 5 April 1733 at Old Aquebogue, Long Island.¹ Hannah Terry died on 17 October 1774.

     Joshua Tuthill INSCRIPTION: Old Burial Ground, 1990, John Asher:
Aisle #11-Q4
IN MEMORY OF
MR. JOSHUA TUTHILL
WHO DEPARTED THIS LIFE
JUNE 2, 1782
92 YEARS





BIRTH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

DEATH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

BURIAL:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I22914@ @I4919@. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 5CC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0115D. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 15C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0C9DE. He was born in 1690 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.^1,2 He was the son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Joshua Tuthill married Hannah Reeve circa 1719 at New York. Joshua Tuthill was buried in June 1782 at Old Burial Grounds, Cutchogue, Long Island, New York. He died on 2 June 1782 at Cutchogue, Suffolk, New York.³

     Dorothy Tuthill married Joseph Browne BET. 1714 - 1715 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 39C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0ED1E. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 6EC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0237D. Dorothy Tuthill 'DOROTHY TUTHILL, daughter of John and Mehitable (Wells) Tuthill was born in Southold, L. I. between 1690 and 1700 and died Feb. 4, 1774 as the wife of Joseph Browne who died July 14, 1751.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 81.





BIRTH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

DEATH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I12850@ @I4777@. Her married name was Browne. She was born in 1692 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. She was the daughter of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Dorothy Tuthill died on 7 February 1774 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.¹

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 80C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0359D. Daniel Terry Person Source.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: F7C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0AAEF. He was born circa 1708 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. He married Elizabeth Tuthill, daughter of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne, on 26 February 1730/31 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York.² Daniel Terry died between 23 January 1761 and 26 June 1761 at Brookhaven, Long Island, New York.

     Freegift Tuthill Al Cavalari 11 Dec 2003 1:21 PM
Freegift TUTHILL was born on 8 Aug 1698 in Southold, Long Island, NY. He died in Sep 1765 in Goshen, Orange County, NY. He is the one who moved up here to Orange County, NYfrom Long IslandHe and other family members, including grandson Joshua Tuthill are buried in the plot behind my house. I live in the house they built on what is left of the 400 acre farm


Built by one of Orange County New York's founding families
Originally part of a 400 acre tract purchased by Freegift Tuthill in 1730. He was born 1698 in Southhold, Suffolk County, Long Island
Sources conflict. A log house was built in 1732 and then a stone house in 1744. Or the stone house was built in 1733. Its location remains unknown. All seem to agree that the stone house was torn down in 1814 when the present house was built.
Freegift, his wife Abigal, and various other family members are buried out back in a family cemetery. Pictures of the gravestones will be added to this site as well as more pictures of the house's details. The house is about 2900 sqft has 4 fireplaces and two outbuildings.
Freegift died in Sept 1765.
It is interesting to give his lifetime a context: The Stamp Act, which was the first event that really spawned the colonial agitation leading to the American Revolution, was not even to go into effect until November 1st of that year. Freegift Tuthill was a English colonist at a time when separation from The United Kingdom would have seemed as imaginable as a moon landing to most people. England's last of four colonial wars with France, The French and Indian war, had only just ended in 1763. His son, Freegift Jr. died in that war at age 25. The Tuthill's were not yet Americans. They were English colonists.
It is believed that Freegift's grandson, Joshua, built the current house. He also rests out back.
The Tuthill name remains prominent in Orange and Ulster counties. There is at least one business, at least one road, and a hamlet bearing the name.

Taken off the internet 1/20/2004 by Paul A. Brown. Not sure of source.





@I28236@ @I5038@. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 84C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F039DD. He Person Source.¹ He Person Source.² He was buried at Tuthill Family Cemetery, Hamptonburgh, Orange, New York.³ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 55C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00AED. He was born on 8 August 1698 at Oysterponds, Li, Ny. He was the son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Freegift Tuthill married Abigail Goldsmith in June 1727 at Cutchouge, Suffolk, New York.⁴ Freegift Tuthill died in September 1765 at Hamptonburgh, Orange, New York, at age 67.

     Daniel Tuthill Campbell: Daniel Tu115 pg. 191.





@I22910@ @I4918@. He Person Source.¹ He Person Source.² Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 9AC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04F3D. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 4DC31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0015E. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 53C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F007BE. He was born in 1695 at Oysterponds, Suffolk, New York. He was the son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Daniel Tuthill married Prudence Goldsmith on 3 November 1727 at Southold, Long Island.³ Daniel Tuthill married Jemima Paine on 22 March 1749/50 at Southold, Long Island, New York.⁴ Daniel Tuthill died on 19 October 1785 at Aquebogue, Suffolk, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: FDC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0B04F. Sarah Ford was buried at Morristown, Morris, New Jersey. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID ACC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0615D. Her married name was Tuthill. She was born on 20 July 1732 at Morristown, Morris, New Jersey. She married Samuel Tuthill, son of John Tuthill III and Elizabeth Browne, on 3 November 1751 at Morristown, Morris, New Jersey. Sarah Ford died on 12 November 1811 at Morristown, Morris, New Jersey, at age 79.¹

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 69C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F01D1E. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID AEC41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0637D. Jemima (Hannah) Tuthill



BIRTH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I28237@ @I5039@. Her married name was Chalker. She was born in 1705 at Southold, Long Island, New York. She was the daughter of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells. Jemima (Hannah) Tuthill married Isaac Chalker on 30 September 1731 at Southold, Long Island, New York. Jemima (Hannah) Tuthill died in 1750 at Eastbury, Connecticut.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 55C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00AED. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID D4C41366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F089DD. Abigail Goldsmith Person Source.¹ She was buried at Tuthill Family Cemetery, Hamptonburgh, Orange, New York.² Her married name was Tuthill. She was born on 9 August 1710 at Cutchouge, Suffolk, New York. She married Freegift Tuthill, son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells, in June 1727 at Cutchouge, Suffolk, New York.³ Abigail Goldsmith died circa 1779 at Hamptonburgh, Orange, New York.

     Henry Tuthill Person Source.¹ He 'HENRY TUTHILL, son of Henry and Alice (Gooch) Tuthill was baptized in St. Mary's church, Tharston, Eng., June 28, 1612, married Bridget whose maiden name is not known, and emigrated to New England, settling first at Hingham, Mass., where he had a planting lot at Broad Cove in 1635 and a house lot in 1637. He was freeman in March 1638 and Constable in 1640. He sold his property in Hingham, June 20, 1644 and removed to Southold, L. I. He and his wife both died before 1650, she as the wife of William Wells of Southold.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 79.
(cont. from source: J. Tuttle Families...)
(A) (According to C. E. Banks book 'Planters of the Commonwealth,' Henry Tuthill and his wife Bridget of Saxingham Co. Norfolk, sailed from Ipswich on the Mary Anne of Yarmouth. William Goose was master of the ship wihich arrived at Boston on 20 June 1657 (Mayflower's voyage landed 1820). He first settled and purchased a lot In Highman, Massachusetts, sold it in June, 1644, and moved to Southold, Long Island, New York, where his brother John had been for some years.
According to (C) Alva Tuttle in 'Tuttle-Tuthill Lines of America.' After Henry's death his wife, Bridget, also died soon after her marriage to William Wells. A well researched summary of 'The Tuthill Family of Tharston, Norfolk, Co., England and Southold, Suffolk Co., New York' appears in the 1987 Volume 2 of Geneologies of Long Island Families, by Henry B. Hoff, Baltimore Geneological Publishing Co., covering livelihood through to Azariah Tuthill born in 1724. (6). He Person Source.² He Person Source.³ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID C2C61366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F079DB. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 97C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04AEF. He was christened on 28 June 1612 at St. Mary's Church, Tharston, Norfolk, England. He was born after 28 June 1612 at Tharston, Norfolk, England. He married Bridget Elizabeth Burton in 1634 at England.⁴ Henry Tuthill died in 1650 at Milford, Connecticut.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 78C81366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F03159. Daniel Tuthill Deacon Campbel: TU13, pg. 163.Bible of Daniel Tuthill in possession of Ruth Tuthill, gives Daniel Tuthill's birth as Jan 23 1680. 'Departed this life in the year 1762. Mehetiable his wife born Feb. 17, 1679, and departed this life 7th Sept 1757.'

'28. June 4, 1746 Daniel Tuthill, Sr., deeded one-half of Plum Island to Daniel Jr. for 100 pounds. Daniel Jr., by will gave all his Plum Island land to his sons Peter and Rufus (will proved in 1768). This same year John, son and heir of Daniel jr. releases the same land to Rufus, his brother. In 1769 Peter and Elizabeth (Hutchinson) Tuthill conveyed half of their land at Plum Island (half of the Island) to Rufus the brother of Peter. Later deed should be found at Riverhead.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg. 31.)

'528. The will of Daniel Tuthill, of Goshen, N.Y. (James4, John3, John2, Henry1, names sons Daniel, John, Phineas, Samuel, and other children. Will dated 23 Feb., 1761; sworn to 28 Sept., 1761. Administration granted to wife Susannah, etc., 13 Oct. 1761. (Lib 23, p. 130, New York Wills.)'

Bits of Southold History. Notable Marriages:
'Perhaps the oldest man ever celebrating a marriage in Southold, at least the oldest so far as can be learned, was Jonathan Goldsmith Horton, who at the age of 81 years and 6 months was united in matrimony to widow Bethiah Overton Brown, aged 66. Mr. Horton, or 'Uncle Goopie,' as everybody called him, was the sixth direct Jonathan to live in the 'old castle' on the home lot of Barnabas Horton, who in 1640 built his home where George C. Terry's house now stands, corner of Horton Lane and Main street. Uncle Goopie was Drum Major of the 107th Regiment, N. Y. Militia, in 1812, and Deputy Sheriff of Suffolk County in 1814.
'In this old Horton House occured a double marriage in the year 1706, viz., Henry Tuthill to Bethiah Horton, and Daniel Tuthill to Mehetabel Horton Henry and Daniel were brothers and grandsons of the first John Tuthill of Southold, and Bethiah and Mehetabel were granddaughters of the first Barnabas Horton.
'This Bethiah Horton who married Henry Tuthill was great-great-grandmother to Mrs. Anna Harrison, wife of President William Henry Harrison.' (Long Island Traveler, Friday, September 3, 1909, pg. 918.). He Person Source.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: C7C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F07BFE. He was born on 23 January 1679/80 at Oysterpond, Long Island, New York.² He was the son of John Tuthill and Deliverance King. Daniel Tuthill Deacon married Mehitable Horton, daughter of Jonathan Horton and Bethiah Wells, circa 1705 at Southold, Long Island. Daniel Tuthill Deacon died on 7 December 1762 at Oysterpond, Long Island, New York, at age 82.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: C7C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F07BFE. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 7AC81366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F03379. Mehitable Horton Campbell: pg. 263 - wife of Daniel - TU13.

Daniel's Bible: 'Mehetiable his wife was born Feb 17, 1679 and departed this life 7th of September 1757.' She Person Source.¹ Her married name was Tuthill. She was born on 17 February 1679/80 at Southold, Long Island, New York, USA.^2,3 She was the daughter of Jonathan Horton and Bethiah Wells. Mehitable Horton married Daniel Tuthill Deacon, son of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, circa 1705 at Southold, Long Island. Mehitable Horton died on 7 September 1757 at age 77.²

     Abigail Wells Wells, Walter M., pg. VIII. unm. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 7CC81366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F03599. She was born in 1657. She was the daughter of William Wells and Bridget Elizabeth Burton. Abigail Wells died in 1658.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 7EC81366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F037B9. Jonathan Horton Wells, Walter M. pg. VIII, pg 20, & 21.

ANCIENT LONG ISLAND EPITAPHS:
Also at his feet lie the remains of his youngest
son
Jonathan Horton
the first Captain of Cavalry
in the County of Suffolk
He died Feb. 23 AD. 1707. AE. 60.

Horton Families in America: 'Jonathan Horton, born in Southold, Long Island, New York, 23 February 1648; m. Bethia Wells about 1672; d. 23 February 1707.' pg. 59. 'Military Service by generation: Second Generation: Jonathan Horton I. 'He was the first Captain of the first Company ever organized in Suffolk County, New York and his brother, Joshua, was first Lieutenant of the same Comany.' See 'Moore's Indexs of the Town of Southold,' No. 248, page 90.'

'Jonathan2 Horton, youngest son of Barnabas,1 died in Feb., 1706/7. He Inherited the homestead of his father, maintaining with increasing notoriety the high standard of fame which his father had won for it. His father, with his characteristic energy and power to accomplish the plans he conceived, settled each of his four older sons on farms as they came of age. The property of Jonathan's wife, Bethia2 Wells (Wm.1) swelled the number of his fields, meadows, and woods....Jonathan and Bethia were worthy members of society and much respected in the community. (Town Records and Horton Genealogy.'' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 83.)

'214. The direct descent of Bethia Tuthill, wife of Samuel2 Landon, (Nathan1) in her Horton ancestry was: 1. Barnabas Horton, burried in an alter tomb at Southold, died July 13, 1680, aged 80 years; he was born in Mousely, Leicestershire, England. (Whether Mary, the wife of Barnabas, was his only wife, or his second wife or the mother of his children, seems uncertain.) 2. Capt. Jonathan Horton, born at Southold, Feb. 23, 1648, died there Feb.23, 1707, married there about 1672, Bethia2 Wells, daughter of William1 and Marie (Youngs?) Wells, born about 1653 or 1655, died at Southold April 14, 1733/4. 3. Bethia Horton, born about 1674, died at Southold Mar. 16, 1744 (Horton Bible, brought by Barnabas to America), married in or before 1690. Henry3 Tuthill (John2 Henry1), of Southold, born there May 1, 1665, died Jan 4, 1750, also at Southold, 4 Bethia Tuthill, born Dec 12, 1703, died Aug. 30, 1761; married May 26, 1721, Samuel2 Landon, Judge in Suffolk Co. before the Revolution.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 75.)

'Jonathan, son of Barnabas Horton I. and Mary Langton, born in Southold, L. I., 1648; married, about 1672, Bethia Wells, daughter of Wm. Wells, Esq., one of the original thirteen settlers of Southold.
'Children: 1. Caleb, born 1673; died in infancy. 2. Bethia, born 1674. 3. Barnabas, born 1675; married Elizabeth Burnette. 4. William, born 1677; married Christiana Youngs. Settled in Orange Co., N. Y. 5. Mehetabel, born 1679; married 1. Peter Bradley, 2. Dea. Daniel Tuthill. 6. Abigail, born 1681; married 1. Lyon, 2 David Brewster; settled in Orange Co., N. Y. 7. Jonathan, born 1683; married Mary Tuthill. 8. Mary, born 1687; married David Horton. 9. Caleb, born 1690; married 1. _______. 2. Widow Mary Goldsmith. 10. Patience, born 1692; died unmarried. 11. James, born 1694; married Anna Goldsmith.
'Jonathan, youngest son of Barabas Horton I., resided with his father and inherited the homestead.
'He was the first Catain of the first company of cavalry ever organized in Suffolk Co, L. I., N. Y. and his brother Joshua was 1st Lieutenant of the same company.
'He and his wife were worthy members of the Southold Church, and highly esteemed in all the relations which they sustained.
'For further particulars see Moore's Indexes of Southold, No. 348, page 90.
'Captain Jonathan Horton made his will Feb. 21, 1707, and died on the 23d, two days afterward.
'His wife, remaining his widow, died April 14, 1733.
'An inventory of the goods and chattels of Captain Jonathan Horton, late of Southold, who deceased Feb. 23, 1709...' (The Hortons in America, Being a Corrected reprint of the 1876 work by Dr. Geo. F. Horton. Compiled by Adaline Horton White, 1929, pg 407 & 408.). He Person Source.¹ He was buried at Southold Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island, New York.² Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: B7C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F06AEF. He was born on 23 February 1647/48 at Southold, Long Island, New York.^3,4 He married Bethiah Wells, daughter of William Wells and Bridget Elizabeth Burton, circa 1672.³ Jonathan Horton was buried in February 1706/7 at Southold Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island, New York. He died on 23 February 1707/8 at Southold, Long Island, New York, at age 60.⁵

     William Wells Walter M. Wells (1915-) 'William Wells (1605-1671) pg. VIII.

'WILLIAM WELLS, supposed son of Rev. William Wells, Dean of Norwich, England, was early of Lynn, Mass, and died in Southold, L. I. Nov. 13, 1671, aged 63 years. His imposing gravestone is still standing in the old Presbyterian Cemetery at Southold. He married before 1650, Bridget, whose name is not known. About 1654 he married second, Mary, or as she wrote it 'Marie' who is said to have been a Youngs, but no foundation for the tradition has been found. She married second in 1678, Thomas Mapes, and died in April 1709, aged 90 years. The day William Wells died he deeded his wife Mary, his home, lands, goods and chattels that she might maintain herself and children.
'William Wells was Deputy from Southold to the General Court of New Haven in 1635, 1657. In 1657, 1658 and 1659, Constable at Southold. Town Clerk, 1650, also Attorney at New Haven and Arbitrator at Southold. In 1661 he was appointed Magistrate. 1664 found him a member of Governor Nicoll's Council. In 1665, Deputy from Southold to the New York Colonial Assembly at Hempstead. He served as High Sheriff of the eastern part of Long Island, in 1665 and 1669.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 83.

'211. It would be best to make the birth date of Wm. Wells, Gent, 1605-'8. His tombstone give the latter, but the former is the date of the birth of William, son of Wm. Wells, of Norwich, England, Rector of St. Peter's Mancroft Church at Norwich. ...' The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 74.

'Here lies ye Body of William Wells, of Southold, Gent. Justice of ye Peace & first Sheriff of New Yorkshire Upon Long Island, who departed this life November 13, 1671, aged 63. Yea Here He Lies Who speaketh yet, through dead, On Wings of Faith his Soule to Heaven is fled. His Pious Deeds and charity Was such That of His praise, no pen can write too much As was his life, so was his blest Decease, He liv'd in love, and sweetly dyed in peace.' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 88.)

No. 22 Lib. A, 155. 'November 13, 1671, William Wells of Southold gives to his wife Mary Wells all his property for her comfortable subsistance and for the education of his children. Speaks of his children and also his oldest sonne. Witnesses Barnabas Winds, Richard Terry. Entered on record Sept. 17, 1672 by Richard Terry.' (Collections, Historical & Genealdogical of Suffolk County New York, by Joseph H. Petty., film #0017929, pg. 32.). Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 76D61366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F03D0B. He Person Source.¹ He Person Source.² He was buried at Southold Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island, New York.³ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 99C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F04C0F. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 9DC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0504F. He was born on 10 February 1603/4 at Norwich, Norfolk, England.⁴ He was the son of William Wells. William Wells married Bridget Elizabeth Burton in 1654 at Southold, Long Island, New York. William Wells was buried in November 1671 at Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island. He died on 13 November 1671 at Southold, Long Island, New York, at age 67.

     William King died BET. 1650 - 1651 at Salem, Massachussetts.¹ He Person Source.² He Person Source.³ He Campbell, pg. 59, item 178-180.

Long Island Traveler, pg. 59, item 178-180. 'William and Dorothy King...landed with six children at Salem in 1636.

'1. WILLIAM KINGE of Salem, Mass. was born in England about 1595 and is first traced in a list of one hundred and six passengers entitled ' Bound for New England, Waymouth, ye 20 March 1635.' This list includes the names of William Kinge, aged 40, Dorothy his wife aged 34, Mary his daughter, aged 12, Katheryn his daughter aged 10, William his son, aged 8, Hannah, his daughter, aged 6.
'In the Register of the Abbey Church of St. Mary at Sherborne, Dorset, is the following entry: '1616-17, Feb. 17, William Kinge et Dorothiae Hayne nupt.'
'On reaching New England they settled at Salem, Mass, where he was made freeman March 25, 1636 and received the same year a grant of forty acres at Jeffrey's Creek, now Manchester. In 1638 he received thirty acres at Royall Side at the head of Basse River, now Beverly, where the King homestead was situated, which stood until about 1840 when it was taken down and the site is now occupied by the Asylum and School for Deaf Mutes.
'The name of William King appears in a list of Salem Grand Jurors in 1637 and also on the roll of members of the First Church. He took an active part in the religious controversies of the day and in 1637 identified himself with the Antinomians, a step which placed him under the ban of the Salem authorities and he was admonished to sever his connection with that sect, under penalty of being disarmed, and refusing to do so, he was directed to leave his gun with Lt. Danforth.
'He died intestate about 1650/1. His widow Dorothy and his son William settled the estate under the direction of the court and in the settlement is mentioned the daughter Deliverance aged 9 years besides the other children born in England.
'In 1652 his widow purchased of John Swazey his dwelling house and land, lying between that of Richard Hyde and Daniell Rumball on the South River; also a tract of land in the South Field. In 1653, she sold same and in 1658 when giving testimony, she stated she was about 60 years of age. In 1684 she received commonage in Southold, L. I. where several of her daughters had taken up their residence, and she probably died there.' Frost, Josephine C. 'Yates-Terry Genealogy', Film #1020788, pg. 53..

Additional information compiled by Lucy D. Akerly from the Manuscript Genealogy of Rufus King of Yonkers, N.Y. Taken from the book, 'Genealogies of Long Island Families', Henry B. Hoff, 1987':

'There was also another son Samuel King, born about 1635 whose name is not included in the ship's list, dodubtless on account of his being so young, but his King parentage is clearly set forth in legal papers recorded at Salem relating to the distribution of his father's estate....
'William Kinge on reaching New England, settled at Salem, Mass. where he was made freeman 25 March, 1836, and received the same year a grant of 40 acres at jeffrey's Creek, now Manchester also in 1638, one of 30 acres at Royal Side at the head of Basse River, now Beverly, where the King homestead was pleasantly situated.
'The land rose with a gentle slope to the level of a broad field and the road turned to the left beyond the house, passing over the bridge part way up the hill; the King acres were on both sides of the bridge.
'...Mr. King died about 1650 intestate; his widow Dorothy and son William settled the estate under the direction of the court at Salem, where papers on file mention the following children; William the eldest son, Samuel aged 18, John aged 13, Mary, wife of Mr. Scudder, Katheryn, wife of John Swasy, Mehitable aged 15 and Deliverance aged 9.
'...'Doritha King, widow and Relict of William King, Senr.' in the testimony of Michael Shaffin, aged about 80 years; in 1684, she received commonage of one acre at Southold, where her daughters Hannah, wife of Lieut. Richard Brown, and Deliverance,wife of John Tuthill were then living.
'This partial history of the King family includes only the early generations descended from samuel and Frances (Ludlam) King, who were the progenitors of the Long Island branch.
'The Kings of Massachsetts are the posterity of a younger brother John King of Salem, who married Elizabeth, daughter of Thomas and Elizabeth Golthwait of that place and was the ancestor of many of the name who have filled positons of honor and trust in the community...'

'919. In the Library of the British Museum in London, the manuscript department contains papers relating to the Seymour family of Trowbridge.
'These documents are classified as Additional Manuscript, 32, 327, and date from 1614 1665. Of these papers, Nos. 108 and 109 refer to a religious sevice described as 'an unlawful meeting of Anabaptists and Phanatiques,' held in North Bradley, Wiltshire, which led to the arrest of William King of that place and their incarceration in the gaol at Fisherton, Salisbury. Could this religious enthusiast have been William King, the Antinomian, who came from Engand to Salem, Mass., in 1635? His son Samuel King, born 1633, died 1721, was the founder of the Southold family.'The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 298.

'Absalom4 King was born Saturday, 6 January, 1703-4. He was the son of Samuel3 King, who was born 23 March, 1675. Samuel3 was son of Samuel2 King who was born in England about 1633, and came to America with his father William1 Kinge, born about 1595. They sailed from Weymouth, Dorsetshire, England, 20 March, 1635. (See Rufus King's article in New York Gen. and Biog. Record for April, 1901.)...' (The Long Island Traveler, Fiche #6016168, pg 379.). Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 78D61366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F03F2B. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 6BC31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F01F3E. He was born circa 1595 at of Weymouth, England. He married Dorothy Hayne on 17 February 1616/17 at Abbey Church of St. Mary, Sherborne, Dorset, England.¹

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 6BC31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F01F3E. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 7AD61366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0414B. Her married name was King. Dorothy Hayne was born circa 1598 at of Weymouth, England. She married William King on 17 February 1616/17 at Abbey Church of St. Mary, Sherborne, Dorset, England.¹ Dorothy Hayne died after 1684 at of Southold, Long Island, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 15C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0C9DE. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 46D71366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00E1A. Hannah Reeve INSCRIPTION: Old Burial Ground, 1990, John Asher:
Aisle #11-Q5
IN MEMORY OF HANNAH TUTHILL
THE WIFE OF JOSHUA TUTHILL
WHO DIED MARCH 18, 1764
AGED 64 YEARS





DEATH:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

BURIAL:Jordan.FTW, Jordan.FTW, Mike Cobb at mcbb1@swbell.net

@I28223@ @I5029@. Her married name was Tuthill. She was born on 3 June 1699 at Mattituck, Long Island, New York.¹ She married Joshua Tuthill, son of John or Chalker John Tuthill and Mehitable Wells, circa 1719 at New York. Hannah Reeve died on 18 March 1764 at Cutchogue, Long Island, New York, at age 64.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: B7C21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F06AEF. Bethiah Wells was buried at Southold Presbyterian Cemetery, Southold, Long Island, New York.¹ Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 5CD71366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0247A. She Wells, Walter M. pg. VIII. Her married name was Horton. She was born in 1655.² She was the daughter of William Wells and Bridget Elizabeth Burton. Bethiah Wells married Jonathan Horton circa 1672.³ Bethiah Wells died on 14 April 1733 at Southold, Long Island, New York.⁴

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 1AD91366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0E478. Joseph Conklin Campbell, pg. 2. Early Long Island Wills - Suffolk County, 1691-1703. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 03C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0B7BE. He was born in 1670. He married Abigail Tuthill, daughter of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, on 1 November 1690 at Southold, Long Island, New York. Joseph Conklin died on 23 November 1698 at Southold, Long Island, New York.¹

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 24D91366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0EE18. John Parker Campbell, pg. 2. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 05C31366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0B9DE. He was born circa 1657. He married Abigail Tuthill, daughter of John Tuthill and Deliverance King, after 26 August 1698. John Parker died on 8 February 1726/27.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 9DC21366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F0504F. Mary Youngs Person Source.¹ She Person Source.² She 'Upon the petition of Mary Mapes, late wife of William Wells of Southold, that under her direction her son William Wells might administer his father's estate is granted 7 June, 1681. [Sessions Book No. 1, pg. 190-10]. Long Island Traveler, 'Long Island Genealogy', Fiche 6016180, pg. 1207.). Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 36D91366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00038. She was born in 1619 at England. She died in 1709 at Southold, Long Island, New York.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 38D91366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00258. Anna Wells Person Source.¹ Her married name was Goldsmith. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 65CD1366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F02374. She was born in 1667 at of Southold, Long Island, New York. She was the daughter of William Wells and Mary Youngs. Anna Wells married John Goldsmith in May 1683. Anna Wells died in 1695.

     Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: _UID 3AD91366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F00478. Her married name was Youngs. Unrecognized GEDCOM data: Unknown GEDCOM tag: 67CD1366D2D4D611BFCA0800460222F02594. Mary Wells was born in 1661. She was the daughter of William Wells and Mary Youngs. Mary Wells married John Youngs Farmer circa 1678. Mary Wells died on 4 November 1729 at Southold, Long Island, New York.